Where Celebs Go

Restaurant · New York

Shelsky's of Brooklyn

Where Marty Markowitz gets lox and Andrew Knowlton stops for kippers and herring.

Instagram
7.1K

Nilou Motamed, Andrew Knowlton & 1 moreLast spotted in May 2014

Directions

What people say

  • Old-school Jewish appetizing counter: smoked fish, bagels and deli sandwiches, with friendly staff.
  • Mostly grab-and-go; only a small seating area, so plan to take it with you.
  • Whitefish salad and the smoked fish builds are the draw for bagel-and-lox fans.
  • Pricey: sandwiches run high but are big enough to split across two meals.

Do it like them

What to order at Shelsky's of Brooklyn

The house favourites

What to order

  • Everyone orders itThe classic done right: nova, scallion cream cheese, chewy hand-rolled bagel or bialy. Get the scallion.
  • Everyone orders itFar more fish than filler, piled on a bagel or bialy. Ask if they've got it.
  • Peppery, glossy and a little bit genius. Best with scallion cream cheese on an everything bagel.

Know before you go

  • It's mostly takeout with just a few seats, so grab a number and take it to go.
  • Study the menu before you reach the counter so the line keeps moving.

Who goes

3 celebs have been

What the stars say

“Shelsky’s for wild salmon”

Nilou Motamed

  • “The lox is usually from Fairway or Shelsky’s on Smith Street.”

    Marty Markowitz

  • “One last stop at the new Shelsky’s for some kipper fillets (they have these really good ones from Stonington, Maine). I also picked up some pickled herring for my wife.”

    Andrew Knowlton

Around the corner

Celeb places a short walk away
Shelsky's of Brooklyn141 Court Street, Cobble Hill Historic District, New York, 11201Open in Google MapsWebsite